House Favorites
Wood Fried Pizza
NY Style Cheese Pizza
Our version of NY style 12" pizza - shredded whole milk mozzarella, local cheddar, DOP San Marzano tomato sauce, oregano, EVOO. Buy 3 for $33. Save $18. Toppings Extra. Discount taken at cart. Great to freeze for later.
$17.00
Margherita The High Life Pizza
Our best seller for good reason - local mozzarella, authentic DOP San Marzano tomato, Agrarian Feast micro basil, EVOO.
$23.00
Wild One Pizza
Wild Boar pepperoni, smoked mozzarella, shaved white onion, spicy Harissa spiked San Marzano tomato. Alderwood smoked sea salt. EVOO. Catskill Provisions pepper infused raw honey accompaniment.
$28.00
The Manor Pizza
Wild arugula, roasted red pepper, aged prosciutto, fresh local mozzarella, San Marzano tomato, 10-year Modena balsamic vinegar.
$25.00
My Italian Friend Pizza
Freshly minced garlic, white onion, aged prosciutto, shaved Parmigiano-Reggiano, San Marzano tomato, live basil, olive oil.
$23.00
Hawaii Five-Oh Pizza
Sweet and Savory - pineapple, prosciutto, and mix of sweet and hot peppers. San Marzano tomato, shredded mozzarella cheese, oregano, EVOO.
$23.00
Mediterranean Retreat Pizza
Kalamata olives, onion, spinach, sun-dried tomato, feta, authentic San Marzano tomato, EVOO.
$25.00
Dreaming of Buffalo Pizza
Buffalo Kombucha hot sauce, organic ground chicken breast, Tonjes Farm blue cheese crumble, micro chives. Butter crust. Blue cheese dip.
$25.00
White Album Pizza
Seven local farms and the wild Catskill forest meet here. House-made wild ramp kale pesto, bacon jam, chevre, aged Parmigiano-Reggiano, egg, broccoli shoots, EVOO.
$29.00
Marinara Pizza
DOP San Marzano tomatoes, oregano, garlic, EVOO. A very tasty red pizza but also a terrific base to customize as you wish. We recommend simply adding anchovies but you're welcome to get creative.
$15.00
The Pepper-Ronnie Pizza (online exclusive)
Start with our NY style 12" pizza - shredded whole milk mozzarella, DOP San Marzano tomato sauce. Add pepperoni, pickled jalapeno, diced garlic. Savory and spicy bliss.
$23.00
The Kaatskeller Pizza Dough
Special blend of traditional "00" and New York organic milled wheat. Great for making pizzas at home. Freeze until ready to use.
$6.00
Saltwater Pizza
New Haven style white pizza with littleneck clams. Arugula, lemon. Ah, summer...
$33.00
Chicken Caesar Salad Pizza (online exclusive)
A tasty combination of our marinara wood fired pizza, local ground chicken and chilled romaine Caesar salad.
$27.00
Small Plate
Flat Bread & Butter
Wood-fired house-made flat bread. Local farm butter. Sea Salt. EVOO.
$7.00
Skillet Meatballs
Hand rolled, local grass-fed beef, Stewed DOP San Marzano tomatoes, Tonjes Dairy Farm ricotta, Agrarian Feast micro basil.
$19.00
Brook Trout Rillettes
House recipe, smoked trout dip. Wood-fired flatbread & chipotle pepper accompaniment. GF upon request. (contains fish and dairy).
$20.00
Tinfoil Trout
Native whole trout. Savory house ramp pesto. Roasted in our wood fired oven with lemon, seasonal vegetable and a starch. Share or entrée dish (GF). A guest favorite.
$34.00
Cider Chicken (new menu item)
Roasted local farm chicken quarter (leg and thigh). Dressed with Catskill honey, apple cider vinegar, herbs and rye whiskey (GF). Tonjes Farm Blue Cheese wedge
$15.00
Salads
Wild Apple Arugula
Wild arugula, aged Italian-style hard cheese, apple, raw walnut. House cider and raw honey dressing. (Gluten-free, vegetarian).
$18.00
Wood Fired Caesar Salad
Wood-fired curly kale or little gem lettuce, curried chickpeas, regular Caesar dressing, parmesan cheese (GF, V, contains nuts).
$17.00
Heirloom Tomato Salad
A summer favorite. Local heirloom tomato, feta, Kalamata olive, red onion, fresh herbs, simple house vinaigrette (GF)
$19.00
Calzones
Sausage & Peppers Calzone
Local sausage, grilled peppers and onions. Mozzarella, ricotta cheeses. San Marzano tomato sauce served on the side. Finished in our wood-fired oven.
$21.00
Sandwiches
Meatball Sandwich
Hand-rolled local beef meatballs. Stewed DOP San Marzano tomatoes. Italian cheese blend. Served on ciabatta. Finished in our wood-fired oven.
$21.00
Kids Menu
Kid's Cheese Pizza
Made the same as our NY-style cheese pizza but 1/2 the size.
$10.00
Desserts
Warm Pear Cider Donuts
Three wood fired cinnamon sugar donuts with sea salt caramel
$9.00
Wood Fired Apple Cider Cake
Sea caramel top. Made for The Kaatskeller by Aunt Nenee
$9.00
Beverages
Assorted Soda 12 oz
$3.75
Sprindrift 12 oz
No added sugar - assorted flavors - selection upon pickup
$3.75
Saratoga Sparkling Water
$3.75
The Kaatskeller
The Kaatskeller is currently located at 39 Main St. Order your favorite pizza, pasta, salad, and more, all with the click of a button.